1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. Guide
Medical billingSwitchingEvery specialty

How to Switch Medical Billing Companies Without Losing Money

To switch billing companies safely, read your contract, choose the new company before you give notice, and agree in writing who works the claims already sent. Then get your data and logins back, update Medicare and your insurers, and watch your numbers every week for 90 days.

Published and reviewed 8 min read By the HealthRescue Partners billing team
Practice manager reviewing billing reports on a tablet

Quick answer

  • Plan the switch like a handover, not a breakup. Read your contract, set a switch date and agree in writing who works the claims already sent.
  • Get your data back. Your A/R report (the list of claims not paid yet), open denials, logins and reports belong to your practice.
  • Watch the deadlines. Medicare claims must be filed within 12 months of the visit, and every insurer has its own limit. Old claims must not sit while companies change.
  • Update Medicare. If a billing company is listed on your Medicare enrollment, report the change within 90 days.
  • Lock the doors. Give the new company its own logins and remove the old company's access on the last day.

What should you do before you give notice?

  • Read your contract. Look for the notice period, any fee to leave, and what happens to claims already sent. That last part is often called the runout.
  • Pick a switch date. The first day of a month is easiest. Claims for visits from that date go to the new company.
  • Choose the new company first. Agree on the price, what it covers and a start date before you give notice, so there is no gap. Our guide How much does medical billing cost? shows how to compare quotes.
  • Sign a BAA with the new company. HHS (the federal health department) lists billing as work that makes a company your HIPAA business associate. Sign the business associate agreement (BAA) before you share patient data.
  • Don't share patient data by email. Use your EHR, your clearinghouse or a secure file share.

What should your old billing company give back?

Ask in writing, before the last day. Your business associate agreement should say the old company returns or destroys patient data when the contract ends, so get what you need first.

Ask forWhy you need it
A/R aging reportEvery unpaid claim, its age and the amount, so nothing gets lost
Open and denied claims listThe claims someone still has to fix, appeal or follow up
Logins and setup detailsClearinghouse, insurer portals, ERA (electronic payment notices) and EFT (direct deposit) setup. Most should be in your name already
Insurance contracts and fee schedulesThe rates each insurer agreed to pay you, to check payments
Credentialing filesYour CAQH login (the online profile insurers check), approval letters and effective dates
Patient balancesWhat patients still owe, and any payment plans
Last 12 months of reportsYour starting point, to judge the new company

Who works the claims already sent?

This is where practices lose money in a switch. Claims sent before the switch date still need follow-up, denials still need fixing, and the deadline clock keeps running.

  • Option 1: the old company finishes them. It keeps working the claims it sent for an agreed time, often under the original contract. Ask for a weekly list until they are all closed.
  • Option 2: the new company takes them over. It needs the full A/R report and denial history on day one. Expect this to be priced as a separate project.
  • Either way, watch the deadline. Medicare requires claims to be filed within 12 months of the date of service. Medicaid and private insurers set their own limits, often shorter, so check each contract.

What do you need to update with Medicare and insurers?

  • Medicare enrollment: Section 8 of the Medicare enrollment form (CMS-855I) lists your billing agency. If it names your old company, report the change. Medicare rules give you 90 days for this kind of change.
  • Electronic claims and ERA: claims and ERA (electronic payment notices) are set up with each Medicare contractor and insurer. If your clearinghouse changes, register the new one. Noridian, for example, uses its EDISS Connect system.
  • Payments stay with you: Medicare always pays in your name, and it won't pay a billing agent whose fee is tied to what it collects. Payments should keep going to your own bank account through the switch.
  • Insurer portals: remove the old company's users and add the new company's users. Don't share one login between companies.

What should you check after the switch?

Look at four numbers every week for the first three months, and compare them with the months before you switched:

NumberWhat it tells you
Claims sentEvery visit is turning into a claim
RejectionsSetup is right. Rejected claims never reached the insurer
Payments postedMoney is arriving and being recorded
DenialsWhether claims are going out clean

A short dip in the first month is normal while setup settles. If it lasts longer, ask why in writing.

How to switch billing companies, step by step

Tick off each step as you go0 of 8 done
Your ticks are saved in this browser.

Switching to HealthRescue Partners

Our medical billing service is 4% of what we collect for you, or $200 a month if that's higher, with $0 to start. That one price includes claims, payment posting, denials and follow-up on the claims we send, patient statements, eligibility and benefits checks, prior authorizations, credentialing support and a monthly report. Coding is $3 per chart if you need it. Our billing audit is free. Most practices are live within two weeks once we have system access and insurer portal logins. We work inside your current EHR, ask your old company for your data with you, and give every open claim an owner. Old unpaid claims from before you join are a separate project, priced after we look at them.

Frequently asked questions

How long does it take to switch medical billing companies?

It depends on your notice period and how fast logins and data move. With us, most practices are live within two weeks once we have system access and insurer portal logins. Plan the old claims separately, because they can take months to close.

Will I lose money when I switch billing companies?

Not if every open claim has an owner and a deadline. Money is lost when old claims sit between two companies until the insurer's filing limit passes. Agree in writing who works them, and check the list weekly.

Who works the claims my old billing company already sent?

Either the old company finishes them for an agreed time, or the new company takes them over with the full A/R report. Decide before you give notice, and put it in writing.

Do I need to tell Medicare I changed billing companies?

If your Medicare enrollment lists a billing agency in Section 8 of the CMS-855I, yes. Medicare rules give you 90 days to report this kind of change.

Can my old billing company keep my data?

Your business associate agreement should require it to return or destroy patient data when the contract ends. Ask for your reports, claim lists and logins in writing before the last day.

Do I have to change my EHR to switch billing companies?

No. A billing company should work in your current EHR or practice management system. We work in most systems.

Do I need to change my bank or direct deposit?

Usually not. Insurance payments should already go to your own bank account, and they stay there. Medicare always pays in your name.

Sources

  1. CMS, Form CMS-855I Medicare enrollment application, Section 8: Billing agency/agent informationReviewed November 21, 2026
  2. eCFR, 42 CFR 424.516(d): Reporting changes in Medicare enrollmentReviewed November 21, 2026
  3. Noridian Medicare, Timely filing (42 CFR 424.44)Reviewed November 21, 2026
  4. HHS, HIPAA guidance: Business associatesReviewed November 21, 2026
  5. HHS, Sample business associate agreement provisionsReviewed November 21, 2026
  6. eCFR, 42 CFR 424.73: Prohibition of assignment of claims by providers (payment to an agent)Reviewed November 21, 2026
  7. Noridian Medicare JF Part B, Electronic Data Interchange (EDI) and 835 ERA registrationReviewed November 21, 2026

This article explains how to change billing companies in plain language. It is not legal advice; read your contract and ask a healthcare attorney about anything unclear. Last reviewed November 21, 2026.

Thinking about switching?

We plan the handover with you so no claim gets lost. Plan your switch with us or call (505) 322-6780.