
Quick answer
- Billing companies charge in one of three ways: a percentage of what they collect for you, a fee per claim, or a flat fee each month. Some add setup fees, monthly minimums and extras.
- Compare in dollars, not rates. Turn every quote into what you would pay for one normal month of your practice.
- Check what the price covers. Coding, denials, old unpaid claims and prior authorizations are often extra.
- In-house billing is not free. Half of medical records specialists earned more than $51,140 a year in May 2025, before taxes, benefits, software and backup.
- Our price: 4% of what we collect, or $200 a month if that's higher, with $0 to start.
How do billing companies charge?
There are three common models. Each one can be fair or expensive. It depends on the rate, what it covers and your practice.
| Model | How it works | Good for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Percentage of collections | You pay a share of the money the company collects for you each month. | Most practices. The company only earns when you get paid. | A percentage of what: collections or charges? Does it apply to payments you take at the front desk? |
| Per claim | You pay a set price for each claim sent. | High-volume practices with simple claims. | Do you pay again for a resubmitted or appealed claim? You pay even when a claim is never paid. |
| Flat monthly fee | You pay the same amount every month. | Practices with steady volume that want a fixed bill. | Limits on claims or providers, and less reason for the company to chase unpaid claims. |
Two words matter in any quote. Collections are the money that actually reaches your bank. Charges are what you bill before insurers apply their contracted rates, so they are always the bigger number. A percentage of charges costs more than the same percentage of collections.
How do you work out your real cost?
Take one normal month of your practice and price every option on it. Here is how each model turns into dollars:
| Option | The math | Example: $30,000 collected, 400 claims |
|---|---|---|
| Percentage of collections | Your monthly collections × the rate | At our 4%: $30,000 × 4% = $1,200 a month |
| Per claim | Claims a month × the price per claim, plus resubmissions | 400 claims × the quoted price |
| Flat monthly fee | The fee, plus anything over its limits | The quoted fee |
| In-house biller | Wages + payroll taxes + benefits + software + clearinghouse + training + cover for time off | Wages alone at the May 2025 median: about $4,262 a month ($51,140 ÷ 12) |
The example numbers show the method only; they are not a quote for your practice. Then add the extras you would actually use, such as coding or work on old unpaid claims.
What should the price include?
Two quotes with the same rate can cover very different work. Ask the company to say yes or no to each of these:
| Work | What it means | Our billing price |
|---|---|---|
| Claim submission | Turning each visit into a claim and sending it every day | Included |
| Payment posting | Recording every insurance and patient payment against the right visit | Included |
| Denials and follow-up | Fixing denied claims and chasing unpaid ones before the deadline | Included, for the claims we send |
| Patient statements | Bills and reminders for what patients owe | Included |
| Eligibility and benefits checks | Confirming a patient's coverage before the visit | Included |
| Prior authorizations | Getting the insurer's approval before certain care | Included |
| Credentialing support | Fixing enrollment problems that block payment, and keeping your CAQH profile (the online profile insurers check) current | Included |
| Coding | Choosing the codes from your notes | $3 per chart, if you need it |
| Old unpaid claims | Claims from before the company started | A separate project, priced after we look at it |
| New insurance applications | Joining a new insurance network | $150 per application |
Also ask about setup fees, monthly minimums, fees to add a provider, fees for reports and fees to leave. If it isn't in writing, assume it costs extra.
What rules protect you when you pay a percentage?
- Medicare money goes to you. Medicare will not pay a billing agent whose fee is tied to the amount billed or collected. It always pays in your name. So a company paid a percentage should never have Medicare payments sent to its own account.
- You stay responsible for your claims. CMS (the federal Medicare agency) says on its enrollment form that you remain responsible for the accuracy of claims a billing company sends for you.
- Ask how they keep coding honest. The HHS Office of Inspector General (the federal fraud watchdog) has long warned that percentage deals may raise the risk of upcoding, which means billing a higher level of service than you provided. A good company audits its coding and won't pay its coders for higher codes.
- Sign a HIPAA business associate agreement. A billing company sees patient records, so HIPAA (the federal health privacy law) makes it your business associate. The agreement says how it protects that data and returns it when you part ways.
Is it cheaper to do billing in-house?
Sometimes, for larger practices with steady staff. For most small practices, the full cost of one biller is higher than it first looks:
- Wages: the median medical records specialist (the government job group that includes medical coders) earned $51,140 a year, or $24.59 an hour, in May 2025.
- On top of wages: payroll taxes, benefits, billing software, a clearinghouse (the service that sends claims to insurers), training and cover when your biller is away.
- The risk: when one person runs all your billing, claims stop when that person leaves.
A middle path is a virtual medical biller who works in your systems, from $10 an hour. You direct the work; we handle hiring and backup. Our guide How to set up a billing department compares the three models.
How to compare billing quotes, step by step
What HealthRescue Partners charges
Our medical billing service is 4% of what we collect for you, or $200 a month if that's higher, with $0 to start. That one price includes claims, payment posting, denials and follow-up on the claims we send, patient statements, eligibility and benefits checks, prior authorizations, credentialing support and a monthly report. Coding is $3 per chart if you need it. Our billing audit is free. Already with a billing company and thinking of moving? Read How to switch medical billing companies.
Frequently asked questions
How much does medical billing cost?
+
Billing companies charge a percentage of collections, a fee per claim or a flat monthly fee, often with extras. The only fair way to compare is to turn each quote into dollars for one normal month of your practice. We charge 4% of what we collect, or $200 a month if that's higher, with $0 to start.
Is a percentage or a flat fee better?
+
A percentage ties the company's pay to your collections, so it only earns when you get paid. A flat fee is easier to budget but gives less reason to chase unpaid claims. Compare both in dollars, and check what each one covers.
What is the difference between a percentage of collections and a percentage of charges?
+
Collections are the money that reaches your bank. Charges are what you bill before insurers apply their contracted rates, so they are always higher. The same percentage of charges costs you more.
Is it cheaper to do medical billing in-house?
+
Not always. One biller's wages alone were about $51,140 a year at the May 2025 median for medical records specialists, before taxes, benefits, software, a clearinghouse and cover for time off. In-house can make sense for larger practices with steady staff.
Can a billing company charge a percentage on Medicare claims?
+
Yes, as long as Medicare pays into your own account. Medicare will not pay an agent whose fee is tied to the amount billed or collected, and it always pays in your name.
What hidden fees should I ask about?
+
Ask about setup fees, monthly minimums, coding, work on old unpaid claims, extra providers, reports and fees to leave. Get every fee in writing before you sign.
Does HealthRescue Partners charge a setup fee?
+
No. Our billing is $0 to start, then 4% of what we collect or $200 a month, whichever is higher. Coding is $3 per chart if you need it.
Sources
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook: Medical Records Specialists (May 2025 pay)Reviewed November 21, 2026
- eCFR, 42 CFR 424.73: Prohibition of assignment of claims by providers (payment to an agent)Reviewed November 21, 2026
- CMS, Medicare Claims Processing Manual, Chapter 1, section 30.2.4: Payment to agentReviewed November 21, 2026
- HHS-OIG, Compliance Program Guidance for Third-Party Medical Billing Companies (63 FR 70138)Reviewed November 21, 2026
- HHS, HIPAA guidance: Business associatesReviewed November 21, 2026
- CMS, Form CMS-855I Medicare enrollment application, Section 8: Billing agency/agent informationReviewed November 21, 2026
This article explains medical billing prices in plain language. It is not legal or financial advice; read every contract before you sign it. Last reviewed November 21, 2026.