
A claim denial code is a short standard code an insurer puts on a remittance to explain why a claim wasn't paid as billed. It has a group code that says who is responsible (for example CO or PR), a claim adjustment reason code (CARC) that says why, and often a remittance advice remark code (RARC) that adds detail. CO-16 with remark M51, for example, means the provider is responsible and the procedure code is missing or invalid.
This guide explains how to read these codes, what the most common ones mean, how Medicare, Medicaid and commercial insurers present them differently, and when to resubmit or appeal.
Rejection vs. denial: know which one you have
- A rejection never entered the payer's system. A clearinghouse or payer front-end edit bounced it, usually for a format problem such as a bad member ID or NPI. It shows up on clearinghouse or claim acknowledgment reports, not on a remittance. Fix it and send it again. Until it's accepted, the filing clock keeps running.
- A denial was processed, and the decision appears on the remittance with codes. Depending on the reason, you correct and resubmit, or appeal.
- Medicare's "returned as unprocessable" sits in between. These claims carry reason code 16 with remark MA130, and Medicare's contractors say they can't be appealed: submit a new, corrected claim instead. An appeal only delays payment and risks running out the filing deadline.
How to read a denial code
A remittance line such as CO-97 / N111 breaks down like this:
- Group code (CO): who is financially responsible for the adjustment.
- Reason code (97): why the claim or line was paid differently than billed. Here, it was bundled into another service.
- Remark code (N111): extra detail or an alert, such as which field is wrong or whether you can appeal.
Reason codes are maintained by an X12 code committee, and remark codes by CMS. Both lists are published on the X12 website, and Medicare loads updates three times a year, around March 1, July 1 and November 1. Codes are added, reworded and retired, so an old cheat sheet can be wrong.
The group codes
| Group code | Meaning | Can you bill the patient? |
|---|---|---|
| CO | Contractual obligation: the provider is responsible under the contract or program rules | No |
| PR | Patient responsibility: deductible, coinsurance, co-pay, or a non-covered service the patient owes | Yes, for the amount shown |
| OA | Other adjustment: used when neither CO nor PR applies, such as a balance passed to another payer | No |
| PI | Payer-initiated reduction: used by some commercial payers when the reduction isn't from a contract term | No |
| CR | Correction or reversal of an earlier decision, paired with CO, PR or OA | Depends on the paired code |
The group code matters as much as the reason. PR-96 means a non-covered service the patient may owe. CO-96 means the same reason, but you must write it off or appeal. Medicare warns that billing patients for amounts not in the PR group can lead to penalties.
The most common denial codes and what to do
Wording in the "Official meaning" column is the standard CARC description. The same reason code can appear with a different group code, so always read the pair.
Missing or wrong information
| Code | Official meaning | Usual cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|---|
| CO-16 | Claim/service lacks information or has submission/billing error(s). | Something on the claim is missing or invalid. The remark code says what: M51 for the procedure code, M76 for the diagnosis, N290 for the rendering provider's ID, and so on. | Read the remark code, fix that field and send a corrected claim. Don't appeal. |
| CO-4 | The procedure code is inconsistent with the modifier used or a required modifier is missing. | Missing modifier (25, 59, 95 and others) or one that doesn't fit the code. | Correct the modifier and resubmit. Check the payer's telehealth modifier rules. |
| CO-5 | The procedure code/type of bill is inconsistent with the place of service. | Wrong place of service, often 02 vs 10 for telehealth, or 11 vs 22. | Fix the place of service and resubmit. |
| CO-11 | The diagnosis is inconsistent with the procedure. | The diagnosis code doesn't support the service billed. | Check the documentation and coding. Correct if wrong; appeal with notes if right. |
| CO-181 | Procedure code was invalid on the date of service. | A deleted or not-yet-active CPT or HCPCS code. | Bill the code that was valid on the date of service. |
Eligibility and coverage
| Code | Official meaning | Usual cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|---|
| CO-22 | This care may be covered by another payer per coordination of benefits. | The payer thinks another plan is primary. | Confirm coverage with the patient, bill the primary payer first, then send its EOB with the secondary claim. |
| CO-26 / CO-27 | Expenses incurred prior to coverage. / Expenses incurred after coverage terminated. | The patient wasn't covered on that date. | Verify eligibility, find the right payer, or bill the patient. |
| CO-31 | Patient cannot be identified as our insured. | Wrong member ID, name spelling or date of birth. | Copy details exactly from the current insurance card and resubmit. |
| CO-109 | Claim/service not covered by this payer/contractor. | Sent to the wrong payer, or to the wrong Medicare contractor. | Send it to the correct payer or contractor. |
| PR-1, PR-2, PR-3 | Deductible, coinsurance and co-payment amounts. | Not a denial: the plan processed the claim and these amounts belong to the patient. | Bill the patient for the amount shown. |
Medical necessity and benefits
| Code | Official meaning | Usual cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|---|
| CO-50 | These are non-covered services because this is not deemed a 'medical necessity' by the payer. | Diagnosis doesn't meet the payer's coverage policy, such as a Medicare LCD (remark N115). | Check the coverage policy. Appeal with records if the service met it. |
| CO-96 / PR-96 | Non-covered charge(s). | The plan doesn't cover the service. With PR, the patient may owe it; with CO, you can't bill the patient. | Check the group code before billing the patient. Use an ABN or waiver before the visit next time. |
| CO-167 | This (these) diagnosis(es) is (are) not covered. | The plan excludes the diagnosis. | Check coding; bill another payer or the patient only if your contract allows. |
| CO-119 | Benefit maximum for this time period or occurrence has been reached. | Visit or unit limits used up, common in therapy and behavioral health. | Check remaining benefits before each visit; request an exception if the plan offers one. |
| CO-204 | This service/equipment/drug is not covered under the patient's current benefit plan. | The patient's plan excludes the benefit. | Verify benefits before the service; the patient may be responsible if they agreed in writing. |
Authorization and network
| Code | Official meaning | Usual cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|---|
| CO-197 | Precertification/authorization/notification/pre-treatment absent. | No prior authorization, or it wasn't on the claim. | If you had one, add the number and resubmit. If not, ask about a retro-authorization or appeal. |
| CO-242 | Services not provided by network/primary care providers. | You're out of network, or the plan needs a PCP referral. | Check your network status and referral rules; appeal for network adequacy if no in-network option existed. |
Bundling and coding edits
| Code | Official meaning | Usual cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|---|
| CO-97 | The benefit for this service is included in the payment/allowance for another service/procedure that has already been adjudicated. | Bundled into another service (NCCI or payer edits). | Check the edit. Add modifier 25 or 59 only if documentation supports a separate service. |
| CO-236 | This procedure or procedure/modifier combination is not compatible with another procedure or procedure/modifier combination provided on the same day. | An NCCI procedure-to-procedure edit. | Review the NCCI edit and modifier indicator; correct or appeal with notes. |
| CO-151 | Payment adjusted because the payer deems the information submitted does not support this many/frequency of services. | Frequency limits exceeded. | Check the policy's frequency limits; appeal with records if more was necessary. |
Provider enrollment and credentialing
| Code | Official meaning | Usual cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|---|
| CO-B7 | This provider was not certified/eligible to be paid for this procedure/service on this date of service. | Not enrolled or credentialed on that date, often with remark N570. | Confirm enrollment dates with the payer; hold claims until credentialing is effective. |
| CO-170 / CO-185 | Payment is denied when performed/billed by this type of provider. / The rendering provider is not eligible to perform the service billed. | Provider type or taxonomy not allowed for the service, or rendering provider not linked to the group. | Check the taxonomy and the provider's link to the group with the payer. |
Duplicates, timing and documents
| Code | Official meaning | Usual cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|---|
| CO-18 | Exact duplicate claim/service. | The claim was sent twice, often while the first was still processing. | Check claim status before resubmitting. Medicare's MACs suggest waiting 30 days. |
| CO-29 | The time limit for filing has expired. | Filed after the payer's deadline. Medicare's is one calendar year from the date of service. | Usually final. Appeal only with proof of timely filing or a qualifying exception. |
| CO-252 | An attachment/other documentation is required to adjudicate this claim/service. | The payer needs records or a form before deciding. | Send the requested documents through the payer's attachment process. |
How different insurers use denial codes
HIPAA requires health plans to use the standard reason and remark codes on electronic remittances (the 835, or ERA). So every payer, from Medicare to a small commercial plan, sends the same code sets electronically. What differs is how they combine them, what they show on paper and in portals, and how you appeal.
Medicare (traditional, Part A and Part B)
- Claims are processed by regional Medicare Administrative Contractors (MACs), such as Noridian, Novitas, Palmetto GBA, CGS, WPS, NGS and First Coast. Your MAC depends on your state.
- You get a remittance advice (ERA or paper) with group, reason and remark codes. The patient gets a Medicare Summary Notice, which uses plain-language messages instead.
- Medicare often attaches a very specific remark code. Read the remark first: CO-16 with M51 (procedure code) needs a different fix than CO-16 with N290 (rendering provider ID).
- Remark N211 ("You may not appeal this decision") appears on timely filing denials and similar final decisions.
- Each MAC publishes denial resolution pages for its top codes. Look up the code on your MAC's site before you correct or appeal.
Medicare Advantage
Medicare Advantage plans are run by private insurers such as UnitedHealthcare, Humana and Aetna. Their remittances use the standard codes, but they apply their own policies, prior authorization lists and appeal processes, so a code that a MAC would handle one way may need the plan's own reconsideration form.
Medicaid and Medicaid managed care plans
- Many state Medicaid programs and Medicaid managed care plans keep their own EOB or explanation codes and publish lists that map each one to the standard reason and remark codes. MassHealth in Massachusetts, for example, publishes lists that match its EOB codes to the CARC and RARC on the 835.
- Managed care plans often use three-character internal codes (for example a plan code mapped to CARC 16 or 252) on their paper EOBs and portals. Look up the plan's mapping before you decide what to fix.
- Filing limits, appeal deadlines and prior authorization rules are set by each state and plan. Check the provider manual for each plan you bill.
Commercial insurers (UnitedHealthcare, Aetna, Cigna, Blue Cross Blue Shield and others)
- On ERAs they use the standard codes. On paper remittances and portals, many also show proprietary explanation codes. UnitedHealthcare's Optum provider remittance advice, for example, uses short codes such as "CB" for coordination of benefits and "WH" for a withhold, explained on the remittance itself.
- Each Blue Cross Blue Shield company is independent, with its own code explanations, policies and appeal forms, even though they share a brand.
- Commercial payers more often use the PI group code and contract-specific reductions, so check your fee schedule when you see CO-45 (charge exceeds the allowed amount). CO-45 on its own is a normal contractual write-off, not an error.
- Filing limits and appeal deadlines come from your contract and the payer's provider manual, and they're often much shorter than Medicare's one year.
Why the same code can mean different things
A reason code like 16 or 96 is deliberately broad. The remark code and the payer's own policy give it a specific meaning. To make this more consistent, the CAQH CORE operating rule for uniform use of reason and remark codes requires health plans, including Medicare, to use set code combinations in four common scenarios: missing or invalid documentation, missing or invalid data on the claim, a service not covered by the plan, and a service not paid separately. Outside those scenarios, payers can still combine codes their own way.
Correct, resubmit or appeal?
| Situation | What to do |
|---|---|
| Rejected at the clearinghouse or payer front end | Fix and resubmit as a new claim |
| Medicare "unprocessable" (reason 16 with MA130) | Submit a new, corrected claim; don't appeal |
| Wrong code, modifier, date or other clerical error on a processed claim | Send a corrected or replacement claim (frequency code 7), or ask Medicare for a reopening |
| Payer disagrees with medical necessity, coverage or a coding edit, and your documentation supports the service | Appeal with records and a short letter that cites the payer's policy |
| Patient responsibility (PR) | Bill the patient; no correction needed |
| Timely filing (29) without proof | Usually write off and fix the process that caused it |
Medicare's five levels of appeal
| Level | Deadline to file |
|---|---|
| 1. Redetermination by your MAC | 120 days from receiving the initial determination |
| 2. Reconsideration by a Qualified Independent Contractor | 180 days from receiving the redetermination |
| 3. Administrative Law Judge hearing | 60 days from the reconsideration; a minimum amount in controversy applies |
| 4. Medicare Appeals Council review | 60 days from the ALJ decision |
| 5. Federal court | 60 days from the Council's decision; a higher minimum amount in controversy applies |
Most claims are resolved at the first two levels. Commercial and Medicaid plans have their own appeal levels and deadlines, set out in their provider manuals and your contract.
How to prevent the most common denials
- Verify eligibility before every visit, not just the first one. Coverage, plans and primary payers change. This prevents 22, 26, 27, 31 and 109.
- Check prior authorization requirements for each payer and service, and put the authorization number on the claim. This prevents 197.
- Don't bill before credentialing is effective, and keep CAQH, enrollment and group links current. This prevents B7, 170 and 185.
- Code from the documentation and check NCCI edits and modifiers. This prevents 4, 11, 97 and 236.
- Scrub claims before submission and work rejections daily, so nothing ages past the filing limit. This prevents 16 and 29.
- Track denials by code and payer each month. A cluster of the same code points to one fixable process.
How we help with denials
Our denial management service works every denial by its code, fixes what can be fixed and appeals the rest, for 15% of what we recover. Not sure where your denials come from? Our billing audit is free.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a CARC and a RARC?
+
A claim adjustment reason code (CARC) says why a claim or service line was paid differently than billed. A remittance advice remark code (RARC) adds detail to that reason, such as which field is missing, or gives an alert, such as that the decision can't be appealed.
What does CO mean on a denial?
+
CO means contractual obligation: the provider is responsible for the adjustment, and you can't bill the patient for it. Correct the claim, appeal it, or write it off.
What does PR mean on a denial?
+
PR means patient responsibility. The amount, such as a deductible, coinsurance, co-pay or non-covered service, can be billed to the patient or their secondary insurance.
What does denial code CO-16 mean?
+
CO-16 means the claim lacks information or has a billing error. The remark code with it says what's wrong, such as M51 for the procedure code or M76 for the diagnosis. Fix that field and send a corrected claim; with Medicare, a claim returned with remark MA130 can't be appealed.
Do all insurance companies use the same denial codes?
+
On electronic remittances, yes: HIPAA requires the standard reason and remark codes. But many Medicaid programs and commercial insurers also use their own explanation codes on paper EOBs and portals, and each payer applies its own policies and appeal process.
Should I appeal or resubmit a denied claim?
+
Resubmit a corrected claim when the problem was on your side, such as a wrong code, modifier or member ID. Appeal when the payer disagrees with medical necessity, coverage or a coding edit and your documentation supports the service.
Sources
- X12: External code lists (CARC, RARC and group codes)
- CMS Transmittal 13791: CARC and RARC update, May 2026
- Noridian Medicare: Claim adjustment group codes
- Noridian Medicare: Top denials and solutions, Q4 2025
- Noridian Medicare: Timely filing (CO-29)
- First Coast Service Options: Claims returned as unprocessable
- CGS Medicare: Part B appeals process
- CMS: CAQH CORE code combinations for Medicare
- MassHealth: 835 payment advice and EOB/CARC/RARC lists
- Louisiana Department of Health: Medicaid managed care denied claims report (CARC descriptions)
How we can help
This article is general information for healthcare providers, not legal, billing or medical advice. Rules change; confirm current requirements with the relevant agency or payer. Last reviewed November 13, 2026.